| Platinum | Big Mill's Cheesesteaks |
| Gold | Paper Bag Deli |
| Silver | Dave's New York Deli |
| Bronze | Fehrenbacher's Artisan Sausage |
| Top Pick | Brickroad |
| Top Pick | Germains |
| Top Pick | Hogan's Great Sandwiches |
| Top Pick | Publix Deli |
| Top Pick | Subway |
| Top Pick | That Bar and Table |