| Platinum | Metro Diner |
| Gold | Dave's New York Deli |
| Silver | 16th Avenue Diner |
| Bronze | Spurriers |
| Top Pick | 43rd Street Deli & Breakfast House |
| Top Pick | Afternoon |
| Top Pick | East End Eatery |
| Top Pick | Flouthern |
| Top Pick | Northwest Grille |
| Top Pick | The Flying Biscuit Cafe |