| Platinum | Prohibition Pizza |
| Gold | Piesano's Stone Fired Pizza |
| Silver | Satchel's Pizza |
| Bronze | Dave's New York Deli |
| Top Pick | Blue Highway Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Five Star Pizza |
| Top Pick | Leonardo's Pizza of Millhopper |
| Top Pick | O Sole Mio |
| Top Pick | Squarehouse Pizza |
| Top Pick | V Pizza & Sidecar - Gainesville |