| Platinum | Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille |
| Gold | Blue Gill Quality Food |
| Silver | Northwest Grille |
| Bronze | Seafood Dock |
| Top Pick | 352 Munchies |
| Top Pick | Embers Wood Grill |
| Top Pick | Mr & Mrs Crab |
| Top Pick | Northwest Seafood Inc |
| Top Pick | Ocala Conch Man / Conch and More |